Games
Herd Mentality party game
By Big Potato Games
£18.99
££ Proper presentPrice checked 23 September 2026, 02:54
Everyone writes an answer to the same question. The majority wins points. The odd one out gets the pink cow and loses. That is the entire game, and it works. Plays 4 to 20 people with zero rules to learn and maximum shouting. Fast, social, and genuinely funny. • 4 to 20 players • Everyone writes an answer; majority scores, odd one out gets punished • Zero rules to learn • Maximum shouting
View at Amazon UKWhat the crew said
You do not want the clever answer, you want everyone else's answer, which is the whole joke and the reason it gets loud. Four to twenty players, no rules to learn, maximum shouting.
The details
As an Amazon Associate, GiftPod earns from qualifying purchases.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date and time shown and are subject to change. Any price and availability information shown on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Bobbin's verdict
Gets a big table laughing in about four seconds — everyone answers the same question trying to match the herd, and the odd one out cops the pink cow. Brilliant for a crowd; the question cards run down fast, so it's a party piece, not a weekly fixture.
Best for a gathering of 4 to 20 who like guessing what everyone else will say. Ages 10 up, so it clears the kids'-table bar.
Monopoly Cheaters is the longer family evening where the joke is breaking the rules; the Jumbo tumbling tower is the standing-up, drink-in-hand, physical one. Herd Mentality is the quickest to start and the easiest to teach — and the one most likely to come out at a party.
Worth knowing — the boxed questions only go round about twenty, so a group that plays it often will chew through the cards; space it out, or keep it for occasions.
The details: 4-20 players · ages 10+ · 20-30 minutes · one 'Question Wrangler' reads the cards · 8 cows wins, unless you're holding the Pink Cow.